Today I want to talk a little bit about the effect that a positive attitude towards a terminal condition can have and also that of a negative one.
I’m sure you are all aware of a technique called the ‘Placebo Effect’ which is often used when testing new drugs. One group of patients are given the ‘real’ drug and the others a ‘fake’ sugar pill instead. In all other aspects, both groups would be treated the same, none knowing which group they are in.
Now the purpose of this method of testing is that it enables the effects of the drug to be clearly seen. Well at least that is what we are led to believe. In fact the real truth is that research has indicated that around one third of those who took the ‘fake’ pill actually improved just as well as those who took the ‘real’ pill. To further blur the horizon, some of those who took the ‘real’ pill actually got worse.
The ‘Placebo Effect’ is the belief that if you are taking some treatment that you believe is genuine then you will get better, even if the treatment you are taking is false.
Back hundreds of years ago in medical history, some of the treatments were quite notorious, such as bloodletting, treating wounds with arsenic and even the proverbial cure-all ‘rattlesnake’ oil.
No doubt some patients, the conservatively estimated one third of the population who are particularly susceptible to the healing power of the placebo effect, got better with these treatments. Nowadays we know that there is real no medical or scientific evidence to suggest they would do any good whatsoever.
Research carried out by Dr. Bruce Moseley in 2002 demonstrated the same concept but with surgical procedures with people with severe and debilitating knee pain. He tested three groups, two using conventional surgery techniques and the third group went through the surgical process in every respect but Dr Moseley did not actually do any more than cut open the knee and stitch it back after waiting 45 minutes. He even talked through the operations as he would normally do, just in case there was some physiological link between the patient and the operation.
The results were amazing, the two groups who had received the proper surgery, as expected, improved. But the placebo group improved just as much as the other two groups. The placebo group were only told about their fake surgery two years later. Long term there has been no difference in any of the three groups. Dr Moseley actually said after this experiment “My skill as a surgeon has no benefit on these patients. The entire benefit of surgery for osteoarthritis of the knee was the placebo effect”.
So from this we can gather that the ‘placebo effect’ does work on a large number of people.
But there is also something now called the ‘Nocebo Effect’.
This is exactly the same process except based upon ‘not believing’ and being fed negative information. Bruce Lipton in his book ‘The Biology of Belief’ states “In medicine, the nocebo effect can be as powerful as the placebo effect, a fact you should keep in mind every time you step into your doctor’s office. By their words and their demeanours, doctors can convey hope-deflating messages to their patients, messages that are, I believe, quite unwarranted”.
He later talks about the sad fact that a majority of people who are given a terminal prognosis and told that they have only six months to live, almost invariably die within a short period of time.
Over the last few weeks I have read a number of associated books on this subject and am amazed at the information that I have absorbed.
The importance of being positive about surviving a terminal (or other) condition is absolutely critical. Just saying positive things does not appear to work unless you actually believe it, although it helps.
Doing things which are physical such as exercise, changing your diet, taking alternative treatments, body massages, yoga etc. as well as doing some positive thinking exercises will all assist in the process. Add to that the power of working with a specialist in the whole area of ‘mind over matter’ and you are destined to live for a long time.
Now, looking back upon my diagnosed, although I thought I believed what I was told it soon became clear to me that this was all about statistics, finance and the consultant inability and lack of skill in being able to cure my illness.
That glimmer of hope was just enough. I needed to find out more and so I have, resulting in a very positive attitude, a body that I believe in on the mend and a future which I have already pledged to spend encouraging and helping other people who find themselves in the same temporary position as I was.
Well I will stop know, but I hope that I have left you with a few things to think over. Your life may not be the healthiest that it could be, but when something as profound as a terminal prognosis is given you have two choices – either accept it (and die) or reject it, change your life and live until nature takes you eventually.
Enjoy your week …
Regards
Jim Tuffin
I Was The Traffic Genie until this happened!
All comments are welcome below. Feel free to share this blog with other, as I want to help people to understand that there are always alternatives – www.jtuffin.co.uk – Thanks!


Jim are you aware of the “Bug Free Mind” books? The first is about Creating A Bug Free Mind and the second is Using A Bug Free Mind. They are the best I’ve ever come across about getting to grips with controlling your mind and written by a friend of mine who did just that, get control after a horrid business experience. Just google Bug Free Mind and you’ll find them – they really are great and would help you I’m sure.
p.s. I won’t insult you by giving you my live affiliate link – or would it as I think you are an affiliate marketer too, but if you did want to use it, it’s just my name dot com forward slash bug.
Hi Nicola,
THanks for your comment it is much appreciated. I have heard of these books which if I remember correctly were written by Andy Shaw.
I’ll have a look via your link, oh and no offence but affilaite links do not bother me at all. I just want to know what is on offer and if it might be able to assist me.
Thanks again for your support,
Kind Regards
Jim
Fascinating stuff, Jim!
It also makes you wonder about the wisdom of doctors going through the worst case scenarios with their patients, say before surgery. Presumably, this is a consequence of the litigation culture, (e.g. “But Doctor, you didn’t tell me you might have to do that, so I’ll have to sue you!”)
Now that the “Nocebo Effect” is better understood, does this mean that patients would be better off not knowing about worst case scenarios?
Even more challenging: what if a patient’s chances of making a full recovery were actually improved if doctors told a few porkies?
It’s tempting to send these questions to the British Medical Association … and watch the ensuing meltdown!
Hi Doug,
Thanks for your comment. I’ve enough on my plate without pestering the BMA, but from what I have read, they are already well aware of these issues.
Sadly it appears the the huge pharmaceutical companies help fund political parties so tend to get their own way when it come to treatments other than drugs.
If one third of all people could become well by being given placebo’s, I think those companies would get very upset!
Regards
Jim
Dear Jim
What you describe is the difference between fear and courage linked to positive thinking. Your choise to the second category is the right one.The elementary difference between the two is that there are different compounds produced in the human brain which have an huge and still not fully understood influance on your total metabolism of trillion cells in your body.Nor-epiniphrine (adrenaline) secretion has to be avoided
As a scientist with more as half a century of expierience I have also to mention that I like people who think and reven sdmire people who know but.. I have a kind of aversion to people who think they know.
In your case you are classified in the second category and I’m sure you will mke it.
Despite that there are a few basic things that can be very helpful.
Change drastically you eating habits and bring your pH from acid to alkaline – minimum pH.7.2 – Use a lot of curcumin – Use in your drinks drops from the extract of green tea called Epigallocatechingallate – Short EGCg –
If you don’t find it inthe UK ask your pharmacist to get it from Egypt
I’m not akind of an Urban Guru or a sales person for alternative medicine and don’t belong to the category of those who think they know
I’m also not a medical doctor who restricted to the classical medical knowledge.I’m like a mentioned above a scientist “pursang” as the French people decribe it.
Last but not least when the winter is near now try to get regurlarly be heated by a FarInfra Red panel. The method gets more and more attention in scientific circles to fight cancer.The method is classified as Hyperthermia and already in application in some clinics with a department of experimental Oncology.
So my friend I did what I felt I had to do ask you go on to keep up this attitude and somewhere end of 2013 I will visit the Uk again and we can meet for a cofee.
Have a gr8 time
Guy
Hi Guy,
Thanks for your encouraging words.
I have already changed to a alkaline diet and use pH drop to reduce the alkalinity in my drinking water etc. I consume a green concentrate and also take a green tea concentrate as well as avoiding sugary things, dairy and proteins.
Having said that, I do have the odd treat occassionally otherwise what would be the point of staying alive.
I’ll investigate the panels you mentioned but keeping warm is not an issue that I expect to have.
Thank you again for your support, ideas and comments over the last couple of years. It is much appreciated.
Kind Regards
Jim
Well done! Now I’m reading you exploring the missing piece and mo ing towards Missing Peace.
Clive